You've heard it all: Mobsters' remains from the heyday of gambling dumped there, a horde of old cars, to slot machines floating around in the depths of lake.
There's even talk that the dark green-colored vessel of water is bottomless.
Alas, there's a bit to the rumor but not as exciting as it sounds!
A very informed poster at Ancestry.com explains it all:
"There were some tales of the lovers' leaping into the lake, but the lake
does have a bottom and it is fairly deep in the middle.
"It is fed by
springs and is cold all year around. Too cold to swim in, I can vouch
The writer, who did quite a bit of research, continued:
"When I was about 10 or so, a few of us from the 15th & Scott area
belonged to the Behringer Museum up on the top of the Quarry Hill and
we were also
members of the Christopher Guist Historical Society that is on Greenup
St., just South of 7th.
Jerry Berry, Bernie Kramer, Mark Grogan & Mark Eaton diving in Prisoners Lake. Didn't find anything. via Kenton County Public Library.
"Some of us members of the Explorer Club used to
go to the Museum on Saturdays to learn about the Indian artifacts in the
collection there. The interurban street cars that ran out through Park
Hills and Lookout Heights and along Dixie Highway through Ft. Mitchell
to where the Frisch Restaurant was or is now, was the transportation at
that time. There were no buses.
"Well, one hot summer day we decided to try a swim in Prisoners Lake but
it was so cold and slick and deep that we quickly changed our minds and
went down to
the Licking River at the east end of 15th Street, under the C & O
There's more from the writer who identifies herself as Barbara:
"Some time in the 50's, 1950's that is, Prisoners Lake was drained so
that repairs could be made before the dam collapsed.
"There were a couple
and a few slot machines found. I don't think that there were any bodies
or human remains found, but it wouldn't surprise me at all since there
was a "mob" war going on during that time period.
"There were a few mob murders, with bodies found in various areas of
Cincinnati and Northern KY.
"One them was a mob member from Jimmy Brinks
of the Lookout House who was found shot to death in his car up on the Highland
Ave. hill in one of the lovers' lane parking places.
"That guy had about
$50,000 in cash on him when the police searched the car. That kind
of money couldn't be kept by anyone, since it belonged to the mob. I
knew the detectives that did the investigation."
Barbara's account pretty much follows others who have posted about the lake at The Covington News' Facebook page.
Tim Farmer and Tim Slone look for fish in Prisoners Lake in 1992. No mobsters were found! via Kenton County Public Library.
And here's how Prisoners' Lake came about:
A stone quarry existed in the Devou Park area before the Devou Family presented the property to the city for use as a park. In 1916, the Covington City Commission proposed that prisoners from the Covington Jail be put to work in this quarry. A rock crusher was purchased and several small storage buildings were constructed near the quarry, reports the Kenton County Public Library.
The impetus behind the decision to send prisoners to the quarry was financial.
At this time, Covington was spending $18,000 per year for crushed stone for use in building and repairing city streets. Early estimates indicated that the Devou Park operation would save the city at least $10,000 per year.
On April 17, 1916, the first prisoners from the jail were transported to the quarry in the park and were put to work crushing stones," the Library noted.
The operation was not initially successful. Prisoners were typically escorted to the quarry by a single guard. In the first few years of operation, a number of prisoners found the quarry a convenient place to escape.
Over the next few years, the level of the quarry was steadily lowered. By 1924, the quarry had been transformed into a large lake appropriately called "Prisoners' Lake."
The story of Prisoners' Lake is definitely -- Covington Cool!